I don't believe, as many academics do, that the stock market pretty much always prices stocks correctly. This might be true of the stocks in the Standard & Poor's 500 Index ($INX), but of the more than 10,000 tradable stocks, there are many that simply do not have enough of a following for pricing mistakes to be quickly corrected.
If an S&P 500 stock dropped 20% on no news, it's a pretty good bet that bad news is coming. But for most of the other 9,500 tradable stocks, 20% drops can and do occur for reasons that have nothing to do with the underlying value of the company. When these situations occur, they can be great buying opportunities, but you have to be willing to do some homework to make sure that there is in fact no bad news on the horizon.
Elan (ELN) and U.S. Global Investors (GROW), two of my favorite stocks, have suffered large drops in the past two weeks. I have resisted the urge to post immediately after each bad day because I wanted to finish my homework first. Here's what I've found:
Elan
The company presented at the JPMorgan Healthcare conference two weeks ago and left the overall impression that Tysabri sales were ramping nicely and that an Alzheimer's drug (AAB-001), currently in Phase 2 trials, was progressing well. Almost immediately after the conference, the stock started its descent, falling nearly every day.
I think Wall Street was disappointed over the news about the Alzheimer's drug. Apparently, Wyeth's (WYE) CEO -- Wyeth is Elan's partner for AAB-001 -- had previously stated that the companies would "peek" at the data in December 2006, and if the results were "spectacular," they would go immediately into Phase 3 trials. When Elan did not announce they were going into Phase 3 trials, Wall Street inferred that the results must not have been spectacular.
There was even some speculation that Wyeth was going to pull out of the trial.
I had invested in Elan primarily because of Tysabri. I think the Alzheimer's drug could be worth a lot, but it's too early to tell. I regard it more as a bonus rather than the main reason to invest. I was pleased to hear that Tysabri sales were ramping nicely, and speaking separately at the same conference, the CEO of Biogen Idec (BIIB), Elan's partner on Tysabri, seemed to agree.
Tysabri seems to be on track to be a big success this year. Because Tysabri is main reason I invested in the company, I am not going to sell because Wall Street thinks the Alzheimer's results were not spectacular.
About that Alzheimer's trial
Elan and Wyeth are testing four doses of AAB-001. Each group started about four to five months apart. The investigators can "peek" at each group's results at 12 months, and a full evaluation is done at 18 months. In December, I believe, 18-month data from the first group and 12-month data from the second group was available.
In order to justify moving immediately to Phase 3 in December, the results from the two lower doses would have had to be so strong that there would be no hope that results from either of the two higher doses could be even better. By the end of this year, they'll have all the data they need to make the right decision.
I'm glad they decided to wait until they have more data rather than moving ahead prematurely. Only Wall Street and other very short-term investors can be disappointed with this decision.
U.S. Global Investors
It looks like I was too quick to buy back into U.S. Global Investors. I waited until I thought the bulk of the tax-motivated selling was over, but the stock has continued to fall, indicating that there may be something else going on as well.
The reason I invested in U.S. Global Investors is that it runs four of the five top-performing mutual funds of the past five years. In 1999, when the fund I co-managed was the top-performing mutual fund for the previous five years, I saw assets under management increase nearly eight times. I also know that as assets ramped, expenses did not rise as quickly, so profits grew even faster than our assets.
I was disappointed that U.S. Global's assets only doubled in 2006. But I think it brought in a lot of new shareholders and performed well for them last year. Between now and April 15, when their funds' shareholders decide where to invest this year's IRA and 401(k) contributions, I think U.S. Global's assets under management are going to get another bump up. In doing my homework, I've not come across anything that changes this opinion.
Although the business is fine, the way it has handled their latest proxy has become somewhat of a self-inflicted wound. In November, the company announced a 2-for-1 stock split and a special dividend of 50 cents per share (25 cents per share post-split). Frankly, it does not matter to me whether they split the stock. Just as splitting a slice of pizza doesn't get you any more pizza, splitting a stock does not increase the value of the company.
The problem is that once you tell Wall Street that you're going to split your stock and pay a dividend, you'd better do it. That's where this became a self-inflicted wound.
Most public companies incorporate in Delaware so they know they will be treated the consistently with other public firms. Under Delaware law, a simple majority is enough to carry the vote. U.S. Global Investors, however, is incorporated in Texas, and Texas law requires a two-thirds majority vote to approve U.S. Global's proposals.
More than 50% of the company's shares have voted in favor of the proposals, but when it did not get the required two-thirds vote, the company adjourned the shareholders meeting. This gives it more time to get out the vote, but it also increased the risk in Wall Street's view that the split and dividend might not happen. The number of shares of U.S. Global that have been shorted has ballooned and now represents about 25% of all shares outstanding.
A proxy worth your attention
Usually, it's not worth an individual investor's time to vote on a proxy because the management team generally has enough votes lined up to pass its proposals before the proxies are even mailed out. But this time it's different. Your vote could matter.
The record date for the proxy vote was Nov. 20. Anyone who owned stock on that date is entitled to vote. Shareholders can go directly to U.S. Global's Web site or call 1-800-USFUNDS. The voting deadline is Jan. 31 -- Wednesday.
The sooner this is settled, the sooner the company can get back to growing four of the five best-performing mutual funds of the past five years. If you own the stock, I recommend that you vote in favor of the proposals so we can put this episode behind us. That way, we can get management's attention back to growing the business -- and get the stock price back to where it was before this all started.